Talent Acquisition professionals and recruiting managers are the gatekeepers of organizations. And across the rapidly changing TA landscape, it would be naive and shortsighted not to acknowledge an innate bias in the hiring DNA of businesses. Preferences – unconscious or conscious – seep into various stages of recruitment, perpetuating inequalities and impacting decision-making during the hiring process. A nuanced understanding of this sociological tendency and its various facets needs to be proactively tackled.
Bias in hiring refers to prejudice or favoritism that may implicitly or explicitly influence recruitment decisions. Talent Acquisition biases can manifest in various forms including gender bias, racial bias and age bias. Recognizing and addressing these is essential in fostering a fair and equitable hiring environment and ticking all the industry-related DEI (diversity, equity and inclusion) boxes.
A simple example: Bias can manifest when favoring individuals who share your background or have similar past experiences, leading to a tendency to trust their experiences more due to commonality and familiarity. While this may seem logical, if taken to the extreme, it could lead to the unintentional hiring of more individuals who are just like you.
Diversity and inclusion initiatives are profoundly impacted when biases go unchecked, with organizations running the risk of creating homogenous workforces that lack diverse perspectives; hindering innovation and perpetuating systemic inequalities.
When people are marginalized, they fail to have opportunities in employment. They don’t become productive members of society. So I believe that organizations have a responsibility to provide work and opportunity for all people.” – Joanne Lockwood, founder and CEO of SEE Change Happen
How can recruitment managers navigate these challenges and overcome hiring bias to build a more inclusive and diverse workforce?
Leverage technology and AI tools
Artificial Intelligence (AI) – paired with human-led expertise and intuition – is proving its worth as a pivotal role player in identifying and mitigating bias in the initial phases of the hiring process. By automating and standardizing processes, AI can reduce bias. With the implementation of AI-driven recruitment tools, organizations can analyze data without human bias, resulting in a more objective evaluation of candidates. These tools help in screening resumés, conducting initial interviews, and even predicting candidate success based on skills and qualifications.
Additional tools – such as blind recruitment, diverse interview panels, and structured interview processes – will all work towards minimizing the impact of bias in your Talent Acquisition processes.
Prioritize education & training
Ongoing education and training programs are becoming key components of an effective Talent Acquisition strategy to combat bias in hiring. Recruitment managers should schedule and facilitate regular training for hiring teams, educating them about unconscious biases and promoting the inherent value of conscious and inclusive hiring practices.
By fostering awareness and understanding, organizations can empower their teams to make more objective and equitable hiring decisions. This involves sensitizing hiring teams to the different forms of bias and providing them with the tools and knowledge needed to make unbiased decisions.
How you hire and who you hire can make or break an organization and recruiters need the support of the most senior people at a company to ensure that the talent coming through not only aligns with the business goals but is critically intolerant of any subtle biases.
Build a culture of inclusion
Creating a culture of inclusion – without a sense of tokenism – is fundamental in the fight against hiring bias. Organizations need to find ways to naturally and sensitively foster an environment where diversity is celebrated, and where employees feel valued and respected, irrespective of their cultural, religious or ethnic backgrounds. This Talent Acquisition shift requires commitment from leadership, transparent communication, and a continuous feedback loop to ensure that bias is continually addressed.
Most importantly, an organization should prioritize raising awareness within recruiting departments about the importance of diversity and inclusion. Before starting the recruitment process, it’s crucial to discuss potential biases. This approach is more effective than merely monitoring diversity as a Key Performance Indicator (KPI). It will also garner greater support and buy-in from managers compared to highlighting their failure to meet generic cross-organizational KPIs.
Monitor and evaluate
If you want to ensure that instilled and creeping biases are consistently addressed, then continuous and intentional monitoring and evaluation of the recruitment process are essential.
This will involve analyzing data on candidate demographics, reviewing diversity metrics, seeking feedback from candidates and diverse interview panels and conducting regular audits of recruitment practices to timeously identify areas for improvement.
By keeping a vigilant eye on these processes, organizations can proactively address and rectify any emerging biases and engage with departments in an attempt to strengthen their teams. This will happen more easily when existing biases are recognised, acknowledged and worked on.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
In the pursuit of a diverse and inclusive workforce, the Talent Acquisition industry must confront the issue of bias in hiring head-on, with recruitment managers driving positive change within their organizations. This, in turn, positively impacts public employer brand perception.
By understanding bias in its various forms, implementing proactive strategies, and fostering a culture of inclusion, organizations have a unique opportunity to reshape their recruitment processes and contribute to building workplaces that thrive on diversity.